Yes and no.
The sounds coming from the Fractal and modern modelers have much higher production value than tones from 60/70/80/90s.
My point was that modern tastes for guitar tones were developed from the internet "click algorithm", and the majority of those tones were done with modelers. And that feeds back upon itself. The best modeled tones then are used as a model for future iterations.
After the fact, some people have gone back and recreated the "modern interpretation of tone" with mics. For the past decade (at least) people haven't been listening to old recording for inspiration in their production. The expectation for modern guitar tones was largely set by modeling devices.
The only reason to use analog gear to record is for creativity and inspiration, but anyone doing that (now) are just emulating the production techniques developed over the past decade or so.
To make a crude analogy, its the same reason so many strippers have fake tits. At first fake tits stick out like a sore thumb, but after seeing so many, people start to identify with that look, even though they know its not real.
And now women are all wearing padded push up bras to make it look like they have fake tits even if they dont.