(UPDATED for new FW!) EVH amp vs Axe Fx, QC and TMP...
- Thread starter GuitarJon
- Start date
- Messages
- 9,746
FWIW, I’ve known two of those beta testers for close to 20 years and the idea of either one of them shilling is akin to idea of James Freeman or la szum shilling gear to me, so my defense of these two comes from the same place, I’ve just known the beta testers longer and even off the internet. Frankly, I’m surprised they’d even chance McShred speaking about it publicly as he’s not one to pull punches. They’re both business owners in fields unrelated to gear/music and do the weekend cover band thing.
One thing is for sure, those dudes don’t do high gain chugga chugga stuff, they‘re boutique amp guys, mostly the modded Marshall thing. McShred is always going through amps and jdzialak has some nice older Marshalls and some Suhrs. They’re both also Fractal owners and looking at their recent gig pics/videos, McShred was using his FM9 w/ a Morris amp and jdzialak was using the TMP with the cab (he’s got an FM9 as well), within the last month. McShred tends to be a “Hmmm, what should I use tonight?” kinda guy, with guitars and amps. They both got Fractals for convenience/size reasons……and probably because McShred broke his arm like two times in a row and couldn’t carry shit for a while.
I didn’t read all that TOP thread, I didn’t even read their posts, just wanted to lend my history with them.
One thing is for sure, those dudes don’t do high gain chugga chugga stuff, they‘re boutique amp guys, mostly the modded Marshall thing. McShred is always going through amps and jdzialak has some nice older Marshalls and some Suhrs. They’re both also Fractal owners and looking at their recent gig pics/videos, McShred was using his FM9 w/ a Morris amp and jdzialak was using the TMP with the cab (he’s got an FM9 as well), within the last month. McShred tends to be a “Hmmm, what should I use tonight?” kinda guy, with guitars and amps. They both got Fractals for convenience/size reasons……and probably because McShred broke his arm like two times in a row and couldn’t carry shit for a while.
I didn’t read all that TOP thread, I didn’t even read their posts, just wanted to lend my history with them.
- Messages
- 6,554
that guy clearly has turds in his ears.
- Messages
- 6,554
duzie
Shredder
- Messages
- 1,647
What you are doing requires a thick skin .Once again this has been interesting guys. Perhaps the most controversial one I have done so far... Going into this I wasn't expecting it to go this way, that's for sure!
GTR37
Rock Star
- Messages
- 3,451
Or a dollar in his pocket
the-trooper
Shredder
- Messages
- 1,898
Using the Blaster too much.
the-trooper
Shredder
- Messages
- 1,898
So, what does it feel like to upset a multinational, multibillion corporation with a single videoOnce again this has been interesting guys. Perhaps the most controversial one I have done so far... Going into this I wasn't expecting it to go this way, that's for sure!
GuitarJon
Roadie
- Messages
- 414
So, what does it feel like to upset a multinational, multibillion corporation with a single video
Haha kind of weird? Some of the reactions also have been strange... I don't know if they are really upset. If they are they shouldn't be upset with me, as I said earlier it wasn't my goal to piss anybody off. however, I did talk a little bit to Max and he seems nice and respectful so that's good!
SwirlyMaple
Shredder
- Messages
- 1,329
Yeah, I mean, genuinely good on them for acknowledging it and saying they’ll check it out. I’m not sure they really had much of a choice, but a lot of big corps would’ve just doubled down with gaslighting and said “no, it’s the best, ignore your ears and listen to us!”
Do I really believe it’s just a bug? Eh. But the fact that they were upfront about it within 1 day is the right move for building trust and showing they’re committed to the product. I do believe that it’ll be noticeably improved in the next firmware or two.
texhex
Roadie
- Messages
- 857
I've got the physical amps of the same models of BE-100 and Recto amps that are in TMP. Sweetwater has "demo" TMPs for $1530.
I am soooo tempted to buy one and take all this crap up the street to the studio I usually goof off in and reamp some Lasse Lammert against the Amps, TMP and AXE III. Mic up a real cab there, run the TMP and AXE into the power amps of the real physical amps and just see what is what.
It would be a shit load of work and I can get studio time pretty cheap but it would also be a hell of a lot of fun and I know the guy there would love trying to legitimately match these up vs each other.
www.sweetwater.com
I would expect a lot more people will be shooting out the TMP over the next months. Props to @GuitarJon on the EVH shootout.
Dude, do the Recto next. I know you have one in that amp pile of yours.
Who knows how many more bugs will be uncovered...
I am soooo tempted to buy one and take all this crap up the street to the studio I usually goof off in and reamp some Lasse Lammert against the Amps, TMP and AXE III. Mic up a real cab there, run the TMP and AXE into the power amps of the real physical amps and just see what is what.
It would be a shit load of work and I can get studio time pretty cheap but it would also be a hell of a lot of fun and I know the guy there would love trying to legitimately match these up vs each other.
VMS Recording - Columbus Ohio's Premiere Recording Studio
Columbus Ohio's Premiere Music Recording Studio Experience the ultimate tracking session in our state-of-the-art facility, designed for your comfort. Within our 1,000 square feet live room, boasting 28-foot ceilings and meticulously crafted control room and isolation booths, you'll find a...
vmsrecording.com
Fender Tone Master Pro Multi-effects Guitar Workstation
Multi-effects Guitar Workstation with Amp Modeling, Effect Modeling, 7" Touchscreen, IR Manager, 4 FX Loops, Bluetooth, MIDI, USB, Song/Set List Mode, and Looper
www.sweetwater.com
I would expect a lot more people will be shooting out the TMP over the next months. Props to @GuitarJon on the EVH shootout.
Dude, do the Recto next. I know you have one in that amp pile of yours.
Who knows how many more bugs will be uncovered...
SwirlyMaple
Shredder
- Messages
- 1,329
Time will tell, but it appears they are, hopefully. Not disagreeing with you; I just like to give the benefit of the doubt and encouragement as positive reinforcement when companies do the right thing.Should Fender not take this as constructive criticism ?
Listen to the users and improve your product
- Messages
- 6,782
the-trooper
Shredder
- Messages
- 1,898
Goddamnit, they couldn't squeeze a couple more buzzwords in there?
- Messages
- 381
To illustrate the importance of having the proper impedance curve:
This is our reference amp into an LB-2 load-box vs. the model using the default 4x12 5153 impedance curve:
and here is the same thing except using the LB-2 UK speaker impedance curve:
The matching cab's resonance is higher in frequency and lower in amplitude than the load-box which makes it seem like the model has less bass than the real amp. Once the correct impedance curve is selected the error is eliminated.
Amps with low amounts of negative feedback in the bass region are sensitive to the impedance curve. The 5153 is one of these amps due to its NFB circuit.
eggpl@nt
Roadie
- Messages
- 930
Are you using the RTA block in the Axe to show the difference of two signals? Is that some built-in feature, or are you reversing the phase of one of the signals before summing at the RTA block (or something like that)?
Similar threads
