State of Epicicity
Shredder
- Messages
- 1,090
We saw Maestro last night. I now have a ton of respect for Bradley Cooper; I feel like he's a worker. Many years ago I saw the Leonard Bernstein Omnibus programs, and they were very cool. I remember him having this odd an interesting cadence to his speech, just an interesting way about him, and I feel like Cooper worked his ass off to get that feel just right. I though Carey Mulligan was equally incredible. I had seen her in Inside Llewyn Davis and Wall Street 2, and I did not like her at all, but then I saw She Said, and I fucking loved her. But pretty much every woman in that film was incredible. But she really was incredible in Maestro too, and completely different. I now have her on my radar as in interesting and compelling actor who might just surprise you.
Overall I think the film had a kind of haphazard feel to it, that it was almost a series of vignettes that were meant to gloss through moments in Bernstein's life, and it felt a little hollow to me because it felt like it was not cohesive. I still think Cooper is truly a great director; I just felt like the writing could've come from a stronger vantage point. I don't have the best words for what I'm thinking, but I feel like the film excelled in acting and directing, but fell short in writing.
Huge caveat: I think the dialogue mixing was bad. I think the film had too much dynamic range. The dialogue was mixed so low that you really had to turn it up to get what they were saying, especially with Cooper's and Mulligan's interesting speech rhythms and cadences, but then music would come in and blast your head off, so we ended up watching it with subtitles.
Overall I think the film had a kind of haphazard feel to it, that it was almost a series of vignettes that were meant to gloss through moments in Bernstein's life, and it felt a little hollow to me because it felt like it was not cohesive. I still think Cooper is truly a great director; I just felt like the writing could've come from a stronger vantage point. I don't have the best words for what I'm thinking, but I feel like the film excelled in acting and directing, but fell short in writing.
Huge caveat: I think the dialogue mixing was bad. I think the film had too much dynamic range. The dialogue was mixed so low that you really had to turn it up to get what they were saying, especially with Cooper's and Mulligan's interesting speech rhythms and cadences, but then music would come in and blast your head off, so we ended up watching it with subtitles.