Grunge VS Hair Metal
- Thread starter Piing
- Start date
Piing
Shredder
- Messages
- 1,473
- Messages
- 1,349
I'm guessing this sort of might depend on when you grew up. I was in middle school as grunge got big so that will always be my jam and i kinda thought hair metal was too cheesy/dated even though I was able to love early Metallica and Megadeth based on having an older brother giving me albums.
I could see loving hair metal though, I'm sure it was a blast if you were there and had a good coke connect. At least there were chicks at the shows and dudes who tried to look like them lol.
I could see loving hair metal though, I'm sure it was a blast if you were there and had a good coke connect. At least there were chicks at the shows and dudes who tried to look like them lol.
- Messages
- 9,638
I was born in ‘82, so while I heard a ton of hair metal from my cousins/uncle, one of the first CD’s I ever bought was Nirvana’s Nevermind.
And while I don’t consider AIC to be a grunge band, they’re often tossed in that pile, but I found them fairly quickly and they solidified my love for the darker vibe of music. I dig some stuff that can be considered hair metal, that discussion often gets into the same debates as ‘Is AIC a grunge band’, some will say Whitesnake isn’t a hair band, others will argue they most certainly were….I don’t really care what they’re titled as, I dig a lot of their stuff. Same with Crue and Def Leppard. I don’t know where the ’hair’ aspect begins or ends, I just like catchy songs.
And while I don’t consider AIC to be a grunge band, they’re often tossed in that pile, but I found them fairly quickly and they solidified my love for the darker vibe of music. I dig some stuff that can be considered hair metal, that discussion often gets into the same debates as ‘Is AIC a grunge band’, some will say Whitesnake isn’t a hair band, others will argue they most certainly were….I don’t really care what they’re titled as, I dig a lot of their stuff. Same with Crue and Def Leppard. I don’t know where the ’hair’ aspect begins or ends, I just like catchy songs.
JiveTurkey
Goatlord
- Messages
- 16,469
Bob Zaod
Rock Star
- Messages
- 2,872
My exact thoughts.
Bob Zaod
Rock Star
- Messages
- 2,872
Metallica and Megadeth aren't hair metal though
Right. Back then those bands were as anti-hair metal as it got as far as big signed bands go.
JiveTurkey
Goatlord
- Messages
- 16,469
First wave of grunge was awesome. Though the Pearl Jam window of enjoyment for me was about as narrow of an opening as you ever going to get. Oh he's a baritone-y mush mouth complaining about success and he wants to emulate Neil Young? Sign me up! 
- Messages
- 1,349
Metallica and Megadeth aren't hair metal though
very true. what i meant to say is that i still was able to get into music from the era when hair metal was being made. when i listened to metallica and megadeth in middle school it didnt give that same cheesy/dated vibe that i got from hair metal.
JiveTurkey
Goatlord
- Messages
- 16,469
Well and to be fair; the Black Album was pretty much the Metallica equivalent of hair metal for me
Whether it shared the same lyrical slant or not.I liked a specific window of hair metal. And grunge; if we're being honest. I LOVED the first few Soundgarden albums as well as some AiC as well as Nirvana. I dug other things in that era as well, RHCP, Weezer, No Doubt, Faith No More. We may have had to say goodbye to Winger but I think it was worth it
Jarick
Rock Star
- Messages
- 3,344
Born in '83 so grew up listening to hard rock "hair metal" stuff on the radio, then was really captured by the grunge/alt-rock songs that took over. The rock music of the 90's felt much more like "my" music where the earlier stuff felt like my parents' music.
The music I really love sits somewhere kind of in the middle. Stuff with a heavy Black Sabbath influence, darker and heavier, but with well written catchy songs. So that's most of the stuff in the 90-94 era of AIC, Soundgarden, Nirvana, Smashing Pumpkins, but also Wylde era Ozzy, GNR, etc. I'm not as much into the super raw grunge stuff like Melvins or Mudhoney, or the super cheesy hair metal like Great White or Poison.
The music I really love sits somewhere kind of in the middle. Stuff with a heavy Black Sabbath influence, darker and heavier, but with well written catchy songs. So that's most of the stuff in the 90-94 era of AIC, Soundgarden, Nirvana, Smashing Pumpkins, but also Wylde era Ozzy, GNR, etc. I'm not as much into the super raw grunge stuff like Melvins or Mudhoney, or the super cheesy hair metal like Great White or Poison.
HotRats
Roadie
- Messages
- 978
Metallica and Megadeth aren't hair metal though
I'd choose Metallica and Megadeth over grunge and hair metal any day.
JiveTurkey
Goatlord
- Messages
- 16,469
I might be alone in this but G'N'R is in my top 3 of artists I immediately change the "channel" when they come on. I can't even quantify what causes this it's just reflex at this point.
Los-D
Shredder
- Messages
- 1,484
I liked Winger…Well and to be fair; the Black Album was pretty much the Metallica equivalent of hair metal for me
I liked a specific window of hair metal. And grunge; if we're being honest. I LOVED the first few Soundgarden albums as well as some AiC as well as Nirvana. I dug other things in that era as well, RHCP, Weezer, No Doubt, Faith No More. We may have had to say goodbye to Winger but I think it was worth it
They were amazing musicians but had to make a living. You know, like Mr. Big and Damn Yankees.
Also, I still think the Cherry Pie album is amazing… except for the stupid title track.
Similar threads
