I'm not a huge capture person (have moved on from both Kemper and Quad Cortex, and have an unused Tonex Max license I have never installed), but I don't see the sense in the binary nature of the capture discussion.
Instead of the tech being the worst or best thing to happen to guitar amp simulation, I look at it more as a simple utility like impulse responses. Yes, if you let yourself, you can spend an inordinate amount of time auditioning files in folders trying to find some ever-elusive gold.
Or....you find a source you trust and dial in one or two of their iterations and go from there. When @Burger started making captures of all of his amazing Marshall mods for Quad Cortex, I didn't really need to spend time scrolling and clicking to find something that worked. He has a great ear and captured the essence of each of his mods in 1-2 captures per amp.
No different from the way I'll buy a pack of IRs from, say, York Audio, but rarely use more than the "01" mic mix version of each speaker in the pack.
I get what @Digital Igloo is saying, and that's why I don't mess with the four kaziilion factory IRs that come with my FM9. It's usually either a Dynacab I can tweak in real time or something like @2112's ever-useful TV Mix 7 IR. But I will also use the 1-2 trusty mixes in my York Audio packs. Both ways work, and I'm sure they'll work for Proxy and Agoura living side-by-side.
I do beg of you, tho, DI: Please make detailed metadata a requirement for cloud uploads for Agoura captures. Don't make the same mistakes Neural DSP did.....
Instead of the tech being the worst or best thing to happen to guitar amp simulation, I look at it more as a simple utility like impulse responses. Yes, if you let yourself, you can spend an inordinate amount of time auditioning files in folders trying to find some ever-elusive gold.
Or....you find a source you trust and dial in one or two of their iterations and go from there. When @Burger started making captures of all of his amazing Marshall mods for Quad Cortex, I didn't really need to spend time scrolling and clicking to find something that worked. He has a great ear and captured the essence of each of his mods in 1-2 captures per amp.
No different from the way I'll buy a pack of IRs from, say, York Audio, but rarely use more than the "01" mic mix version of each speaker in the pack.
I get what @Digital Igloo is saying, and that's why I don't mess with the four kaziilion factory IRs that come with my FM9. It's usually either a Dynacab I can tweak in real time or something like @2112's ever-useful TV Mix 7 IR. But I will also use the 1-2 trusty mixes in my York Audio packs. Both ways work, and I'm sure they'll work for Proxy and Agoura living side-by-side.
I do beg of you, tho, DI: Please make detailed metadata a requirement for cloud uploads for Agoura captures. Don't make the same mistakes Neural DSP did.....