MirrorProfiles
Rock Star
- Messages
- 4,529
I don’t really want to keep going in circles on this, but I’ve made this point a few times and it falls on deaf ears.a simple control that dials out some of the warts of the real thing, and gets them closer to a tone they prefer quickly is a good thing.
Improving the tone is way too context dependent and subjective to be achievable with a single knob (even if it’s adjusting multiple parameters). Who’s to say that more warts rather than less might be a better tone in some cases? If someone can’t get what they need with the available controls, is a single knob macro adjusting things behind the scenes going to be the magic bullet that beginners are looking for?
No one has made a valid case on how it can actually help, the only counter argument is “yeah but you haven’t heard it yet!”.
There are tons of innovations and improvements that I think are absolutely a step in the right direction. My take of hype is it’s closer to making people think there is a problem, so they can offer a solution.
If anyone wants to make a suggestion on a tangible way it’ll actually be useful or beneficial, I’m all ears. I’m not sure anyone who’s disagreed with me so far has actually responded to any of the points I’ve made on why I think it’s redundant.
FWIW I can absolutely think of other ways of expanding the capabilities of an amp in an intuitive way that isn’t as complex as adding 50 deep parameters. A single hype knob isn’t the route I’d take, and I don’t really mind. It’s just not to my taste and I don’t think it’s particularly helpful. YMMV, more power to you if you think it’s just the thing you’ve been missing.