No way I can rank these accurately. Spent 3 days arguing with myself about it.
The cool thing, for me, about Mastodon is this: they haven't put out a dud. Not one.
I could change around the order of the top 4 on my ranking, and not have an issue.
This is just what I think, and feel, today.
8.
Remission--Their debut release. Full of passion and intensity. A little rough around the edges in all the right ways.
7.
Once More Around The Sun---Just not as moved as much by this album as others. Many bands would peak with an album this good, though.
6.
Emperor of Sand--Again, their 6th best album by my ranking could still be the best album another band could ever do.
5.
Blood Mountain--This is where I hear the true beginnings of Mastodon taking shape. That moodiness merges with the maniacal mayhem.
4.
The Hunter--Just a great group of songs. This is the most streamlined and direct Mastodon, and it works.
3.
Crack The Skye--Easily Number 1 on many people's rankings. Just a timeless release. I could listen to it a thousand times more!
2.
Hushed And Grim--Maybe not as heavy overall, but the songwriting and performances are second to none. Love this album!
1.
Leviathan--The album where the production matches the talent and execution in the band. Moby Dick and Metal? Yes, please!
Now excuse me while I go listen to more Mastodon.