I'm waiting at the end of that rainbow already.
Things you will enjoy:
- Knobs, knobs, knobs! Just turn a knob, no menus in sight!
- Real guitar cabs.
- Lack of excessive options.
- Pedals are fun.
Things you will miss:
- Those scenes are just real nice so it's one button to toggle sounds. A lot more complicated to program and manage even with MIDI.
- Presets. Found that cool tone that works only with one of your guitars at specific settings on that pedal? Well take a picture and turn those knobs to that setting when you need it.
- Visibility into what your presets do, if you have them.
- Not having to spend money on extra pedals to do things your current set doesn't.
- Not having to deal with power supplies, cabling etc.
- Even a small pedalboard weighs a surprising amount when compared to an equivalent size modeler.
My friend's dad has a large collection of pedals. But he also owns a Helix. He had initially lent her a Zoom G2 Four.
She bought an Epiphone Les Paul and a small tube amp on her own.
When she said that she wanted to build a pedalboard, he gave her some guidelines:
1. Only incorporate pedals which she needs while playing live and also recording (She played on a P&W song recently).
2. Tuner is a must for performing live.
3. One dirt pedal to be used if she encounters a backline amp which she doesn't like.
4. Some pedal for boosting/ solos.
5. Looper pedal/ function on a delay to be used for testing pedal settings before playing at a venue.
Her current board is
TU-2 > Ibanez MT-10 > Katana Mini > DOD Delay > Holy Grail Max > Jamman Express Looper > Hotone Soul press
She still uses the Zoom unit. So those who can afford it, should retain both analog and digital gear.