Every so often, a platform, plug-in or methodology comes along promising to give "the exact tone of (fill in the blank)".
Profiling, tone matching, etc. I remember Toontrack's EZMix promising something similar, and of course they also recently updated that platform with "AI-powered analyzer and amp capturing tools".
In every case, what I get when I plug in my guitar with its pickups playing with my fingers is always different than whatever I heard in official or unofficial demo clips of the product ahead of time. I just don't see why this would be any different. The amp/cab/mic chain is important but is really just filling in a sandwich made of two buns (your guitar/pickups/playing and your playback system).
Most importantly, their results will only be as good as the underlying models powering it, and on that front - I've never been particularly bowled over by their offerings.
I'm not just an old man shouting at clouds. I work with AI every day in my marketing job, and it's only becoming more pervasive. I just don't see slavish recreation of tones ever leading to any sort of "new" music that resonates or inspires anyone.
