Warmart
Shredder
- Messages
- 1,882
See, great Marylanders think alike! I came to a similar conclusion late last night. Stop guessing and be sciencey!I'd suggest using a guitar that you like the feel of as an example. Say it's the Majesty with 9's.
Pull up the String tension calculator, and substitute string for string, but change the tuning and scale to see what gauge comes closest to being the same.
The scale on both guitars on the high e side is 25.5", with a 9, that's 14.4 lbs. Tuned down to B, you'd need a 12 to get the same tension.
On the other end, the low E on the Majesty, using a 42, would be 15.8 lbs. Change the scale to 27", tune to B, a 54 would give you 16 lbs. tension.
In a pack of 12's, they go from 12- 56, so that set would get you that tight low end, due to the multi-scale. I think that's what I'd try.
The heavy bottom in that set is a 60, which takes you way up to 19.8 lbs. That's pretty far, and not very balanced either. Almost 40% tighter than the high string. For drop tunings, maybe that would be a good choice. But with the multi-scale, the guitar is already giving your lower strings more tension. Seems excessive to me.
If instead, you want to use 11's, your top strings are gonna be a bit on the loose side in B std, (only 12 lbs.) but you can plug in the #'s and see how it shakes out.
Specs for this guitar are different depending on the year (and the source of info of course), I just measured (nut to middle of 12th fret, and doubled it).
I'm sure I'm not 100% precise, but here's what I get for scale length of each string, and specs for my current standard set of 10's at E and B:
E B
1 25.50" 10 17.8 lbs 10.0 lbs
2 25.56" 13 16.9 lbs 9.5 lbs
3 25.81" 17 18.2 lbs 10.5 lbs
4 26.00" 26 20.0 lbs 11.7 lbs
5 26.19" 36 20.3 lbs 12.0 lbs
6 26.44" 46 18.3 lbs 11.0 lbs
So the 6th is close to 26.5", not 27" like I thought, lmao. Never trust online specs, ever!
I normally prefer 9's with a straight scale all 25.5" in E Standard, which is:
9 14.4 lbs
11 12.1 lbs
16 16.1 lbs
24 16.7 lbs
32 17.0 lbs
42 15.8 lbs
So, a standard set of 11's (11-15-22-30-42-54) on this guitar would give this in B:
11 12.1 lbs
15 12.7 lbs
22 17.5 lbs
30 15.3 lbs
42 16.7 lbs
54 15.4 lbs
Then I don't have to worry about building custom sets.