Not quite.
Nothing wrong with Noma's viewpoint on the matter of authentic/ideal parameters. That's a valid discussion topic which could have been discussed properly.
Where it went wrong is that NKP stated his opinion as the only true approach and therefore degraded Fractal's approach. That tickles any designer's nerves.
It was NOT a language issue. Noma started insulting dissenting members and telling them to shut up long before the final insult.
Normally I wouldn't go into this here. But Noma chose to post here, and opinions are being exchanged.
BTW, English is not my native language. So anything I write in this post can be interpreted in any way that suits your pov.
Signed by an old grump who lives in a toxic wasteland