First off: Happy New Year!
---
So, while we can discuss skeuomorphism yes/no and all other UI aspects as harsh as we may, I hope we can all agree that IKs Amplitube and ToneX interfaces are downright horrible. It's very easy to click something wrong (such as exchanging a pedal instead of adding one), then there's wasted space on one hand and many things crammed into smaller places on the other hand, plus quite a lot of things just not working well (or quickly). And then there's no undo/redo, which is really, really bad (AT edits are not reflected in Logic's generic plugin undo/redo function).
Let alone you simply can't get through their presets with one fixed input level at all. By now I tried pretty much about every amounts of boosts/cuts, the preset levels are all over the place, and even worse, their gain levels obviously are as well, sometimes so much I'm having a hard time to understand the preset name until I massively alter the input gain, such as "pristine clean" sounds not being clean at all, such as gainier sounds to either have way too little or way too much gain, and even going as far as to completely alter the amp's tone. Add to this that some preset designers must've had too much of that Sadites Cool Aid as there's plenty of presets with "master" compressors, pretty much spoiling the real amp sound, especially as you have to deal with input gain staging a lot, which, at least on clean amps, has a huge impact on the way the master compressor acts. Etc.
But while we're at it (sorry for the OT blurb): Their Studio 4 Max package sure is a great deal (sale until tomorrow). I already very much liked the free version of MODO Drums and the full version IMO really delivers. Some kits sound very nice and tweaking them is pretty easy but can as well become complexed if you wish. Some rather illogical design decisions to be observed here, too, still very usable overall. Most likely to become my go-to for all real drums.
MODO Bass is no slouch, either, but it's a rather mixed variety of sounds and some defaults IMO need tweaking.
The B-3X organ is very good.
And as said before, there's some pretty decent sounds in AT as well. For the time being, whenever I need a virtual fuzz pedal, AT will be my top choice, even if I wished there was one or the other modernized fuzz (coming with some decent onboard tone controls). I will likely create some base amp patches and then only tweak them using pedals.