Andy Eagle ( Guitar repair tech for 30 years )

[la szum]

Or if you were going to replace the guts in a guitar what would you
suggest in the realm of Pots, Caps, and Switches (3-way, 5-way)?

 

[la szum]

 

[SillyOctpuss]

@la szum bet this gets him to answer

Hey @Eagle I've heard modelling is so good now it's impossible to tell the difference between a line 6 pocket pod through a York IR and a gold Klon into a Dumble. What say you?

 

[Eagle]

Or if you were going to replace the guts in a guitar what would you
suggest in the realm of Pots, Caps, and Switches (3-way, 5-way)?

Cts 450 series Switchcraft Oak Grigsby and CRL switches. Higher voltage caps than needed seem to sound different during the sweep. Be more specific then I can be.

 

[Digital Igloo]

@la szum bet this gets him to answer

Hey @Eagle I've heard modelling is so good now it's impossible to tell the difference between a line 6 pocket pod through a York IR and a gold Klon into a Dumble. What say you?

View attachment 36385

Huh. Someone wasn't groking the whole conversation.

 

[SillyOctpuss]

Huh. Someone wasn't groking the whole conversation.

Someone was engaging in good natured baiting for a cheap laugh.

 

[norminal]

@la szum bet this gets him to answer

Hey @Eagle I've heard modelling is so good now it's impossible to tell the difference between a line 6 pocket pod through a York IR and a gold Klon into a Dumble. What say you?

If you want Andy to respond, all you have to do is make a post about Sire Guitars.

 

[newpedals]

Any tips on solving issue of little rust on the bridge of an old guitar which a friend didn't use for years? It's otherwise working well.

Will he need to buy some special products to remedy it or it can be done using everyday household items too?

 

[Eagle]

If it’s just a little a bit of WD40 will reduce it. Preferably remove the part disassemble and spray it thoroughly. Leave it overnight and then brush it with an old toothbrush. This will clean it up.

 

[SillyOctpuss]

If you want Andy to respond, all you have to do is make a post about Sire Guitars.

Bah why didn't I ask about Sire or pot metal?

 

[newpedals]

If it’s just a little a bit of WD40 will reduce it. Preferably remove the part disassemble and spray it thoroughly. Leave it overnight and then brush it with an old toothbrush. This will clean it up.

I will tell him. Thank you.

 

[la szum]

Someone was engaging in good natured baiting for a cheap laugh.

Yup. Have to keep that Gear Forum Membership Card polished up and in good standing.

 

[la szum]

Cts 450 series Switchcraft Oak Grigsby and CRL switches. Higher voltage caps than needed seem to sound different during the sweep. Be more specific then I can be.

Thanks, Andy.

Just thinking it would be a decent idea to upgrade the guts in a
couple of guitars I put some nicer pickups in. I almost felt a little
sacrilegious putting such nice pickups in with such craptastic
electronics.

Mostly curious on Tone Caps in Telecasters.

 

[Eagle]

I like the big wax paper cap with single coils.
Not many people selling them though,

 

[Eagle]

These sound good.

 

[SillyOctpuss]

View attachment 36496
These sound good.

Plus they look really cool

 

[la szum]

I saw a recent Joe Bonamassa interview where he said something about
sourcing old Pots and Caps as a wise investment in honing in on better
tone with a more responsive set of controls.

 

[norminal]

I saw a recent Joe Bonamassa interview where he said something about
sourcing old Pots and Caps as a wise investment in honing in on better
tone with a more responsive set of controls.

I heard that conversation as well…

Can someone explain to me how a vintage 250k pot or 0.22uF oil capacitor can sound better than a modern 250k pot or 0.22uF metal film capacitor when electrically they’re essentially doing the same damn thing?

 

[Eagle]

I heard that conversation as well…

Can someone explain to me how a vintage 250k pot or 0.22uF oil capacitor can sound better than a modern 250k pot or 0.22uF metal film capacitor when electrically they’re essentially doing the same damn thing?

Tolerance is tighter and the sweep is better on the pot and the cap doesn’t just kill all the treble first.
A tight tolerance modern pot and a 200v cap will do.