Why Free as a bird? So many better Beatles songs.
Hello, thanks for reading and for asking! TLDR, I like the song and it has a special meaning to me.
The first time I heard "Free as a Bird," I actually didn't know it was a Beatles song. It was maybe 15 years ago and I was recuperating in the hospital after a serious operation. There wasn't much to do, but I brought a USB drive with several albums on it that I had accumulated but never really listened.
One night, late and after hours, it was dead quiet and I was alone in pain and couldn't sleep. I was listening to random MP3s with ear buds and "Free as a Bird" came on. But it was the Adrian Belew version. I think it was from "Belewprints," a live recording in New York. It was just him singing with a piano (I later found out it was a MIDI rig and he was playing guitar triggering piano sounds, IIRC). As I listened, I forgot all about the pain and felt "free as a bird." So the song has deep meaning for me.
After recuperating, I learned the song from listening to the 1995 Belew recording. I did some reading and found it was a Lennon song, incomplete, that Yoko gave to the remaining Beatles and they did it as we all know in 1995. Belew's live recording was from the same year, and apparently he learned it from the Lennon demo, which is why he doesn't sing a verse or two as Lennon hadn't finished the lyrics, while the Beatles remake added new lyrics and full instrumentation. To be honest, I don't care for the remade Beatles version (nor, FWIW, do I like the more recent one they did, "Now and Then"). So I guess my post was misleading, as I was referring to Adrian Belew's take, not the Beatles one.
I learned how Belew played it from the live recording, working out some of his chording and such, and did my own thing with it making an instrumental solo acoustic guitar piece. First, I transposed it to G, because that enabled better access to open strings and harmonics. I've been playing it on and off as a solo piece for the past few years that way. Last year, I joined it with "Blackbird" for a "Birds Medley," after which I combined that with an earlier medley I did with "Lucy in the Sky" and "In My Life" into what I am calling a "Beatles Suite," which I performed live last March. So, back to the OP after this long story, I am now adding "Yesterday" to the "Beatles Suite" for a live set in September.
If you're interested, here's the live video of the "Beatles Suite," without "Yesterday," from last March. I performed it in at auditorium as part of a community event, with about 120 people in attendance. I might have posted that clip in another thread, along with a bit about the gear, so I'll leave it at that.
Regarding there being "better" Beatles songs, I wholeheartedly concur. As I said, I don't even like what the Beatles did in 1995 with Lennon's 1970s demo. But to me Belew catches the same mood as Lennon. And I also think that "better" is a relative term, begging the question, "Better for what?" The Belew version was better for me at that time and place, and I slowly built the suite around that. There's some very interesting harmonic devices in G to explore between the first three songs of the suite, but this is getting verbose so I'll leave that for another story. Writing this now takes me back to that night in the hospital for which the song gave me comfort. So thanks again for asking about it.