Sleezy E
Rock Star
- Messages
- 2,788
Line 6 Helix Stadium Pre-Launch Discussion
- Thread starter Lysander
- Start date
sashimi
Roadie
- Messages
- 677
You’ve been listening to me play in my living room haven’t you
All you need then is a dogshit drumbeat like from a boss rc-5, and a preset with a -1 octave poly pitch for total dogshit basslines and you can be a dogshit one man band without even putting down the guitar.
Last edited:
- Messages
- 10,137
Sounds dogshit bro!! Love it!!
Sascha Franck
Goatlord
- Messages
- 10,970
Coffee. No wait, that's audio related.
Perrymusica
Groupie
- Messages
- 97
Did they have to rework the IRs on the Stadium cabs? Or did they use the same impulse responses we have today? There are current cabs that I use regularly and think are very good, such as the Cali V30, Moon 75, the new Cartog, Jazz rivet, and the 4x10 US Super.
laxu
Rock Star
- Messages
- 8,375
Yeah when it arrives a lot of the competition does not have an actually competing product. Let's take a look at the major players:
- Quad Cortex. Probably the closest competitor. But will not offer the same breadth of models, routing possibilities, anything like Focus view, Showcase features, footswitch programmability etc. On the plus side it is more compact, and supports captures already.
- Fractal Audio. Way, way behind on UI. Ahead in modeling and amount of models in each category. Possibly ahead in footswitch functionality.
- Fender Tone Master Pro. Hasn't moved forward that much since release. Way behind on the number of fx, routing, footswitching capabilities etc.
- Boss GT-1000/GX-100. Not even close.
- Kemper MK2. Not even close.
- Hotone Ampero 2. It's basically a Helix/QC copy in many ways, so the only plus is the smaller size and pricing.
But realistically the two products I'm interested in are the HX Stadium and the BluGuitar Amp X. While I am certain the HX will be superior in so many ways to the BluGuitar...I still kinda want to see how it is because I genuinely enjoy both Amp 1 models so much, and have been playing traditional amp rigs a lot more lately.
- Messages
- 10,137
Very possibly not anymore.
AlbertA
Shredder
- Messages
- 1,620
Oh do tell?
- Messages
- 10,137
Line6 have built an entire new modelling engine. Stands to reason they've been comparing it to all of the competition. Helix already compares very favourably to Fractal. I can imagine any gap (real or perceived) will only shrink.
AlbertA
Shredder
- Messages
- 1,620
ahhh as in the future - sure could be. Only a few months to find out.
I don't imagine it shrinking at all, and I say that as a huge fan of Helix modeling. Fractal fans will continue to stand on the huge swath of exclusive models like the Cameron Atomica/CCV, JVM 410H, Splawn Quickrod/Nitro, etc.
Cliff won't stand still and will redo his underlying modeling multiple times before, during and after the Agoura models continue to drop.
Honestly, I don't think it matters just like consensus thinking on Axe-FX III superiority did nothing to dent the sales success of the HX line.
paisleywookiee
Rock Star
- Messages
- 9,132
Alright, I’ll post it.
“As guitarists, we live in interesting and exciting times!!”
“As guitarists, we live in interesting and exciting times!!”
BenIfin
Shredder
- Messages
- 1,583
Just my 2c
Purely from a sound and feel perspective in the last 2 years using my FM3, whatever Fractal has released has sounded and felt , i.m.h.o, very iterative in very minor jumps - putting aside all the sycophant comments on the FAS forum.
I would suggest an FM3 FW from 2 years ago will sound a little bit different to today but I would go so far as to say, in a blind test, no-one would reliably pick the difference.
I have no-idea what Fractal is planning, but a Company of their small size simply cannot get even remotely close to the feature set of Stadium for anything like that price .... and remember Agora isn't going to stand still either.
I also dont think that the "brains" at Fractal have more knowledge than the "brains" at L6 ..... this is the whole mythology that Fractal has and does rely on and subtly and sometimes not so subtly traded on.
With respect - that boat sailed a couple of years ago.
Hell, I spent about 2 weeks messing with an Ampero Stomp II 8 months ago and it can sound every bit as good as a Helix or FM3 - you could play "stadiums" [pardon the pun] with that unit and it will give you stunning tones.
The rusted on Fractal people will never move and have already been pre-emptivley shit-bagging Stadium - but they are a very vocal and loyal minority.
My guess is Agora / Stadium is definitely going to hurt Fractal in terms of their sales - plus they are also facing significant economic issues not of their making.
All just speccualtion of course.
AZG
Roadie
- Messages
- 128
While I agree that Fractals many updates are mostly iterative and small by themselves, I'm betting if you loaded up two FMx's, one with todays firmware and one from two years ago and A/B you would probably find the difference notable.
While I do have a Stadium XL on preorder, couldn't pass up 20% off, whether I keep it will largely come down to overall sound and feel quality. The UI looks like a nice refinement of the original Helix and the modeling improvements sound promising. But much of the Stadium is carried over from the original Helix good and bad. So while I would love a unit with a much better UI, I'm not sure I will be willing to give up Fractals massive high quality amp and effects library. Honestly I feel a little bit of deja vu from 10 years ago. Both companies have moved forward a lot, but they both still seem to have the same strengths and weaknesses. Not sure where I will end up this time round, but looking forward to giving the XL a go.
Mongillo19
Rock Star
- Messages
- 7,071
BenIfin
Shredder
- Messages
- 1,583
Yep. And not just that. If one didn't know which one was running the older FW, and just going back and forth, I would respectfully suggest the odd's of reliably picking which is which would be no better than random guessing.
AZG
Roadie
- Messages
- 128
I've never done a A/B with a two year version of Fractal firmware so I can't say for sure if it's really better. But I can't help but think that touch/feel has gotten notably better over the past few years. Maybe placebo, but I do enjoy the tones/feel I get out of the FM3 more than ever today.
- Messages
- 10,137
One of the things in the launch video that @Digital Igloo said was words to the effect of, sample accurate communication between the amp and cab block for speaker impedance curves.
That means - in my reading of it anyway - Agoura is powerful enough to communicate the individual sample-stream across blocks, rather than relying on block-based processing. Which means more accurate representation of signals from sample-buffer to sample-buffer.
In practical terms, this means the two blocks can communicate in "real-time" rather than waiting for the next processing buffer to finish before exchanging data.
Other systems process audio in fixed-size blocks, say 32, 64, or 128 samples at a time. That means the amp block would process its chunk of samples, then hand off the results to the cab block in the next cycle.
That tiny delay introduces latency and temporal “coarseness” in the interaction between the amp and cab, so the simulated impedance curve only updates once per buffer, not per individual sample.
So.... you can assume that Helix Stadium will be more precise AND more accurate than other "older" systems.
I suspect this would've been the big jump between Axe FX II and Axe FX III as well. But that's just a gut feeling thing.
That means - in my reading of it anyway - Agoura is powerful enough to communicate the individual sample-stream across blocks, rather than relying on block-based processing. Which means more accurate representation of signals from sample-buffer to sample-buffer.
In practical terms, this means the two blocks can communicate in "real-time" rather than waiting for the next processing buffer to finish before exchanging data.
Other systems process audio in fixed-size blocks, say 32, 64, or 128 samples at a time. That means the amp block would process its chunk of samples, then hand off the results to the cab block in the next cycle.
That tiny delay introduces latency and temporal “coarseness” in the interaction between the amp and cab, so the simulated impedance curve only updates once per buffer, not per individual sample.
So.... you can assume that Helix Stadium will be more precise AND more accurate than other "older" systems.
I suspect this would've been the big jump between Axe FX II and Axe FX III as well. But that's just a gut feeling thing.
Similar threads
