Initial honeymoon with Tonex is over (not in a bad way), and I’ve started A/Bing with the Helix (using the same IR for both). Comparing Fenders, honestly I can pretty much get 1:1 on Helix (especially with the newer Fender models in the Helix), which was sort of surprising to me.
The big thing is that the Helix fenders need much more bass and a bit less mids… e.g. if you copy a capture’s listed amp settings and convert it from 1-10 scale to 0-10 for Helix (and set the Helix’s mids to 6.8 in the case of Fenders that don’t have a mid control), you have to turn the Helix model’s bass up quite a bit, and the mids down a little, to match the sound of the capture. Not sure if this is a quality of the Tonex or of the Helix Fender models, but I was noticing it pretty consistently across captures and Helix models, at least Fender ones.
I did some experiments with boosts too, and they definitely both react a little differently. It might be related to the bass control thing? Neither sounds less natural, and I’m not sure which is actually more realistic, but it’s just a little different in how things shift. Not really a compressed vs open feeling either (I say this because I’ve felt before that sometimes the Helix amps can feel a little “closed” or small when pushed with a boost).
Re: “feel”, idk. The Tonex definitely felt “better” when first using it, but I can’t say I felt much different when directly A/Bing. Maybe some dynamics differences at extremes, but that’s about it. So I’m thinking some of this was just bias on my part.
I’m going to compare further, but I’m a little surprised because I’m suddenly feeling happier with the Helix amps than I was for a bit lol
The Tonex still has the advantage of having some amps the Helix doesn’t (Benson amps, my love!), but it does have me wondering… maybe not if I should get rid of Tonex, but if I should replace it with a One as a companion to the Helix amps rather than a more complete thing replacing them.
Tomorrow night / soon I’m going to compare Vox sounds. That is something that has always fallen flat for me in the Helix, so I’m curious. I’m also going to experiment with a fuzz into both.
And yeah, none of this is a knock on Tonex at all (I know what thread I’m in haha). It sounds great. Just experimenting!
…and maybe with fresh ears tomorrow I’ll totally change my mind lol