Ok, so first impressions.
Hardware
- Very good form factor!
- Excellent headphone out, as expected.
- I like the simplified footswitches. Don't really need much more than color coding here.
- Stereo TRS main input would have been nice so you could use it as a stereo input multifx box. I guess they want you to buy the VP4 for that.
- Not fond of the push-in power button. A little toggle switch would've been nicer. Obviously this is a very minor complaint and doesn't really matter as long as that switch keeps working.
- Power supply with switchable plugs for different regions is nice.
- Not a fan of the Select knob. I totally understand why they chose that and in practice it's less bad than I thought...but I still feel like I'd prefer a small game controller style D-pad in its place.
- Knobs not being clickable sucks! That would have opened up so much potential functionality.
User interface
- It's pretty easy to get confused by the different switching modes as you scroll through the Home screen. I'm sure I get more used to them with time. Mostly just used Effects and Amp modes, whereas with past Fractal products it was always Scenes.
- Amp mode is great! I really want this for every block so you can easily switch channels and tweak them at the same time!
- Love the levels screen! It makes leveling your preset so easy!
- The streamlined UI (less pages) really does help.
- Turning on Expert mode especially in the Amp block instantly brings you into the bad parts of Fractal's previous products where you have to scroll past half a dozen pages you don't care about.
- Being able to easily go in and out of Expert View is great.
- I wish it did a bit better job at keeping the current page as it sometimes jumps to the first page of the block even when you are on a "normal view" page like say Cab.
- Having some amp models bundled into one is a good improvement.
- Already made a thread about Cab block improvements on Fractal's forum.
Functionality
- I miss the Multitap, Plex Delay and Pitch blocks. Don't give a damn about the rest, or having only 1 of everything but drives. Multitap especially would be a good substitute for my Strymon Volante.
- MIDI is again lacking. I wish there were commands to activate the different footswitch modes for example, or to replicate onboard buttons and footswitches like Helix can. It's clear the Sysex commands for this exist because you can pick the different footswitch modes via AM4-Edit.
- AM4-Edit IR management sucks donkey balls. Why can't it arrange the IR browser on the side panel into folders but just vomits all IR files in one list? Even the default sorting option is not just alphabetical.
- Modifiers could be better, same issues as on Axe-Fx 3.
- The big issue with it is that it doesn't show how the current parameter reacts to different settings. If it showed the param value changing it would be much easier to work with.
- For example I set up Pitch follower to control Amp block Treble and Bass with my 8-string. so that it turns down bass and turns up treble when I play the lowest strings for a clearer sound. As the pitch goes higher, it turns up bass and turns down treble. It's just very hard to figure out optimum settings for these when you have to go back and forth to see the effect on value.
- No way to quickly jump between editing blocks. I read on Fractal forums that they think of adding "double click Page" for that. I hope they do.
- Footswitch hold: Custom mode's Channel Picker seems to be broken. It will always show the channel picker for the channel of that footswitch, rather than the currently selected block.
I think like 2 hours just flew by having fun with this thing. It feels like coming home, all the familiar and great tones I had with the Axe-Fx 3. Took me no time at all to churn out a preset on the onboard UI because it was so familiar in many ways.
Unsurprisingly, it sounds absolutely fantastic and it took me very little time to get my favorite amps in play.