I think that opinion depends a lot on what your thoughts were going into buying the Soul Food. I had no idea it was considered some sort of Klon clone. I didn't even really know what a Klon was or sounded like. I bought the pedal and made my decision based on the tones I was able to get out of it. I don't think it is a turd at all. I have found a few tones in it that I really like with both humbuckers and single coils. If your expectations were that you were getting a cheap Klon clone that was 100% accurate or you are a high gain player, I can see why you would think it is a turd.