Would you buy a guitar for your two year old?

OrganicZed

Roadie
Messages
563
My son is nearly two and he has become very interested in my guitars. Almost every day he asks to play dad's guitars. He also asks to look at guitars on my phone (look at my Reverb feed) and he tells me which ones he likes. When we're in the car he says that he wants to hear guitar songs (music that is guitar forward). My wife told me that he has outright rejected most of the songs on her playlist because they don't feature guitar very much. His rejection of the Mariah Carey Christmas stuff earlier this week was particularly swift and forceful. :rofl

He currently has a little toy guitar with strings and he does play with it some on his own, but he mostly just brings it to me and then asks to go play dad's guitars. I suspect that what he likes about playing with my guitars has more to do with spending time engaged with me and playing with the things that I value rather than a genuine desire to make music himself. He spends half of the time flipping switches and moving knobs on the guitars and amplifiers, so I think the tactile play with important stuff is part of the appeal as well. He likes buttons of any kind right now.

Christmas and his birthday are coming up and my wife suggested getting him 1/2 scale guitar of his own. There are aspects of the idea that I like.
1. A lot less reason for him to bash his grubby little hands (or feet and tongue) on my prized guitars.
2. He could play a "real" guitar any time he wants and it won't require my supervision.
3. If his interest continues to grow could use it as his first instrument. He lacks the coordination, focus, and discipline to start any kind of actual musical instruction right now.

On the other hand, I don't want to push him to play just because it is something that I enjoy. Also, if my suspicions are correct and he mostly likes it because it is something that we do together, giving him a guitar of his own might not provide him with any additional fun.

Did you buy a guitar for your young kid(s)?
Would you do it again?
Am I overthinking this?
 
I see no reason not to go with your wife's plan!

Regardless of the reason, and of course he wants to do Dad stuff - you absolutely should encourage him and see where it goes.

Just don't get mad if he loses interest, it's going to happen. But he may surprise you!
 
No thoughts one way or the other on buying the kid a guitar, but I found sessions run by this group to really cultivate a lot of intuitive understanding/appreciation of music in both my kids. Currently have a couple of ukeleles, digital piano, and acoustic drum kit, none of which got more than a couple months use max, with neither kid having any interest in band, etc…but both are able to carry a vocal melody unaccompanied quite well with very solid sense of both pitch and rhythm, which I trace back to going to those classes with them.

Regardless, the classes honestly were pretty fun, got me a lot more singing loudly in front of others, and through that had a positive impact on my own musicality.

 
Do it, and make sure its a guitar you've wanted all your life. Reminds me of the time Homer bought Marge a bowling ball with his name engraved on it. :LOL:

season 6 episode 3 GIF
 
Seriously, though...

Did you buy a guitar for your young kid(s)?
Would you do it again?
Am I overthinking this?
Yes.
Probably, but then again I'm an idiot.
Yes, but is there any alternative?

I think it's a great gift idea. Just go into it with zero expectations. Best case is it opens up a whole new world for him. Worst case is minor consumer guilt and one more paperweight to dust around. I can speak with greater authority on the "worst case" lol.

Make sure you also get him what he asks for. ;)
 
So the Tom Anderson Hollow Cobra, too?
The "also" was supposed to imply "besides a guitar".

But yeah, if it weren't for the whole "kid needs a short scale" thing, I'd also recommend buying something you yourself dig, as an out for the aforementioned "worst case scenario".

(I got stuck with a first gen Fretlight guitar, which somehow seemed like a good idea when I bought it. In my defense, it was very inexpensive. In my daughter's defense, for having ignored it completely, it was also very cheap. And then I lost the stupid cables and the stupid software, and then that's all it was. Cheap.)
 
Last edited:
The "also" was supposed to imply "besides a guitar".

But yeah, if it weren't for the whole "kid needs a short scale" thing, I'd also recommend buying something you yourself dig, as an out for the aforementioned "worst case scenario".
"He's really digging the drum lessons?"

"So you want to buy a drum kit that you'll put in your office when he stops playing?"

"He really likes the drum lessons?!?!?!?"

*9 months later*

"Sooooooo... should I just move this drum kit out to my office kiddo or what?"
 
Back
Top