I had something of a revelation today. It surprised me quite a bit.
Ever since 2003, when I got my first one, I had sort of a thing for Dumble style amps. I had a half-dozen iterations of Two-Rock models until my tastes changed in 2014 and I wanted something more '60s oriented, thus the PRS HXDA, a Plexi style amp cloned from Duane Allman's actual "Live at the Fillmore" amplifier (the Allmans were PRS amp endorsers and got Paul Smith the amp to clone for obvious reasons).
Nevertheless, I always wondered if I should have also kept the T-R, and have said maybe I'd get one down the road.
Today I started listening to some clips of a Dumble style amp on another forum, and then went down the Dumble tone rabbit hole.
The surprise was that other than the stellar clean tones, I thought the overdrive tones were too mid-focused, and too compressed for my taste. The dynamic range, the rawness, the low frequency heft of a great amp were (speaking only for myself) missing. In short, I wouldn't want to use the classic Dumble tones any more, and while they all sound a bit different, there's a strong family resemblance in Dumble-land.
I began thinking that in a one-to-one comparison, I prefer my Mark VII (and other amps) more. In fact, quite a bit more. If someone said to me, "Hey, I've got a new Dumble style amp here by [insert name of favorite Dumble cloner], it cost me $5100. But I'll trade you for your Mark VII straight up," I'd say no way.
I'd turn him down for my least expensive amp, Mesa's Fillmore 50, too. Clearly my tastes have come full circle to pre-2003 days.
Too bad I can't be living in 2003 again, because I'd be a heck of a lot younger and better looking, but...so it goes.
++++++++++++++++++++
The other thing that happened:
I switched a couple of my PRS electrics from the pure nickel strings I've been using for about a decade to D'Addario's XS strings. I couldn't find my brand and faves, the manufacturer was out of stock, and I needed a string change. I like the XS Bluegrass set I have on my acoustic, so I figured, WTF, cheap thrills - I'll try these nickel-plated steel strings just for grins.
They're good strings, and I like them, but they forced me set up my amps differently. Not just the Mark VII; all the amps!
They're hotter than the pure nickels; they're a lot brighter too. I thought I'd need to turn down the gain on my amps, but that made things worse! These strings needed MORE gain!
Completely unexpected! This still makes no sense to me, but to get that creamy tone I like and was getting at lower gain with the vintage style pure nickels, I needed to gain up the amps a bit. However, I did have to pull the treble and presence way down.
Just goes to show ya...every little thing results in a tone change, and often things are different from expectations.
Suddenly I find myself using the Mark VII mode on Channel 2. I've been messing around with the Mark III and IV modes on Channel 3, too. I still don't do Guzz....guzz-guzz-guzz Chugchug, Guzz....guzz-guzz-guzz Chugchug high gain metal, but it's pretty cool to have an amp that has tones I can make use of in every mode, without exception.
You're simply never out of good tone with the Mark VII, doesn't matter what you're playing. No, it won't do every single tone in the history of the world, but it has a pretty substantial variety on tap, and I don't find myself saying, "this amp just doesn't work for this song." On the contrary, it works in some way with everything I do.
Apologies for going on and on about this amp so often; I've simply become an enthusiast.