- Messages
- 14,788
Amp in the room. Headphones. "FRFR". Studio Monitors. IEM. It's all different. Pretty much come to the
realization that each of those is a distinct category, with it is own unique properties. There is simply no
way to collapse the loud amp in the room vibe---while playing live with other musicians---into the studio
monitors box. Just not happening. Likewise, with trying to shoehorn a different sort of monitoring/playback
system into another.
I am also convinced that they are not only all different, but that each can be good to great. I love the
stereo imaging of using a modeler with the playback system of a set of studio monitors. Sitting
in the middle of that is with some tones. I can't get that kind of imaging with a tube amp and cab,
no matter how big the cab is, or isn't. At the same time, I can't get the air moving, and the HEFT in tone
with studio monitors that I can with a cooking amp and guitar cab. Studio monitors will never get my
tone that big and impactful.
Just feels to me like some of us (all of us? most of us?) run into issues when we try to get one of these
monitoring solutions to be another. Maybe we just need to enjoy them for what they are, what they offer,
and what they don't---and not try to make one of them mimic another one of them.
Play on!
realization that each of those is a distinct category, with it is own unique properties. There is simply no
way to collapse the loud amp in the room vibe---while playing live with other musicians---into the studio
monitors box. Just not happening. Likewise, with trying to shoehorn a different sort of monitoring/playback
system into another.
I am also convinced that they are not only all different, but that each can be good to great. I love the
stereo imaging of using a modeler with the playback system of a set of studio monitors. Sitting
in the middle of that is with some tones. I can't get that kind of imaging with a tube amp and cab,
no matter how big the cab is, or isn't. At the same time, I can't get the air moving, and the HEFT in tone
with studio monitors that I can with a cooking amp and guitar cab. Studio monitors will never get my
tone that big and impactful.
Just feels to me like some of us (all of us? most of us?) run into issues when we try to get one of these
monitoring solutions to be another. Maybe we just need to enjoy them for what they are, what they offer,
and what they don't---and not try to make one of them mimic another one of them.
Play on!