Meh, taking you at your word on this, there is a healthy dose of ignorance here that doesn't take thaaaaaaaat much "what makes a tele sound like a tele?" google searching to learn a bit about. The metal base plate of the bridge pickup, and the wire/cover/bobin size of the neck pickup being the biggest contributors. As for the other stuff...discussing it on a gear forum is of little use. Play guitars, see what you think.
So I took your advice at face value and did a search for “what makes a Tele sound like a Tele”.
This threw up a link to the Telecaster Forums, which seemed like a reliable place to get information, so I clicked and went in.
Here is an example of what people on the Telecaster forum say.
One guy says it’s the pickup. Another says it’s the baseplate. You say it’s something else altogether.
Do you see the problem? What do you recommend, that I conduct a statistically weighted analysis to find out what most users think on the Internet and then go with that answer?
Or should just go with your opinion?
I’m sorry you find the thread annoying, but there are no stupid questions, only stupid answers.
Why am I asking questions on this particular forum? It seems like a good place, folks seem knowledgable, geared discussions are interesting, music being shared is cool,
I don’t have access to a lot of instruments to test my theories, and so I ask questions. Some guys on here have huge collections, I hope to get valuable insights.