Yes. I know this, Andy. I was expecting someone to EVH the fuck out of me for that. :lol That said, I still stand by the general trajectory
of what I was saying----even if we can nitpick about exceptions here and there. Because that is what we do here, no?
Besides, I read this as a personal question about what we individually like, and not a universalist question about what we
should choose, or
what the Nature of Reality will and will not allow us to do??
Also, do we label/call all Humbuckers as PAFs? I don't know. I'd personally draw a distinction. Period correct PAFs can be
quite bright and chimey, can't they? And those are a far, far cry from overwound Humbuckers with various magnet types
that can be all kinds of dark and compressed. The utter opposite of a "PAF."
Heck there might be more tonal variations in the variety of Humbuckers that exist than any other Pickup type. Might be.